Cottage Lighthouse - Cute and up to date! Spacious bungalow with 2 bedrooms with queen beds. 2 bath rooms with oversized showers. Hot tub just out the back door! Sauna in lower level. Washer/Dryer in lower level. Walk to downtown shops/restaurants and only 6 blocks to Lake Michigan Beach. Pet friendly with fenced area for your dog.

Captain's Nook - Upstairs room of the Inn. Simple space for 2 people. Queen bed with standard size Jacuzzi tub/shower with Grohe body sprays, infrared sauna, flat screen TV and small frig. Can be booked solo or connect to Captain Whittaker Suite for a 2 bedroom with 2 bath suite.

Nothing but the best for the Captain! This suite’s great room alone will make you want to extend your voyage. It features a tall, vaulted ceiling with skylights, a fireplace, and a full kitchen and dining area.The large center-island cooking counter makes this suite highly suitable for entertaining. The bedroom has a queen-size bed; the bath has a tub and shower combination

Snug Harbor Suite - A good place to find yourself… in fair weather or foul! Our town’s splendid harbor was named “Snug Harbor” by Paul and Elsie Oselka, whose family developed it into its current popularity. We’ve given that name to this splendid (not too snug) second-floor suite! The airy great room, which looks out towards the back garden, has a vaulted ceiling, skylights, a fireplace, and a efficiency kitchen with under counter frig, stove and microwave!

This ship-shape suite is a landlubber’s delight! Named for New Buffalo’s first hotel, this cleverly appointed suite invites you to stay indoors all day. The cozy cheerful room has a fireplace with flat screen TV and a full kitchen for preparing snacks and meals. This room features a magnificent king size bed. The bath area has a two person Bain Ultra side by side jetted tub with heated backrests and a over-sized shower with Grohe body sprays.

Enjoy the gas fireplace and flat screen TV from the king-size bed. Star-gaze through the room’s skylights or outside on your own deck. Relax in the bathroom’s two-person Sabella Jacuzzi® tub and shower combination. Plenty of room for two!

Named for the river that formed New Buffalo’s harbor, this roomy first-floor suite has a living room with fireplace, full kitchen, deck, jetted tub and king bed. Everything you need to renew and relax!

Landing here on the SS Post Boy, Captain Whittaker loved New Buffalo’s spacious harbor so much, he decided to stay. You’ll feel the same way when you discover this spacious suite! The great room with limestone fireplace and entertainment center opens onto a private deck overlooking the Inn’s back garden. The bedroom has queen-sized bed. Plenty of space to move around.The bathroom features a two-person Jacuzzi® whirlpool tub, large enough for two!

Cottage style home with boat themed decor. Perfect spot for your family gathering, 2 story home with outdoor firepit, outdoor hot tub, full kitchen, living room with electric fireplace, main floor has one queen bedroom and 1 full bathr. On the 2nd floor is a dormer with 4 beds, 1 queen, 2 twin and 1 trundle bed. Full bath (shower). Perfect for a group of friends and couple with children. Dog Friendly with pet fee.